Hyper-V Winning Daily/VMware FUD Reaching New Heights.

Hyper-V Winning Daily/VMware FUD Reaching New Heights.

  • Comments 16
  • Likes

Virtualization Nation,

I prefer to spend my time talking about the great things we're doing with Hyper-V and Microsoft virtualization. We have a lot of very happy customers today with Hyper-V R1 and the upcoming R2 release delivers even more in terms of scalability, performance and new features like Live Migration and much, much more. Unfortunately, I need to take a moment to respond to some VMware FUD circulating the web.

Out on the web, there's an "anonymous" video purporting to show a Hyper-V crash. When I heard, I was surprised and immediately wanted to know more. I haven't heard of any such incidents with Hyper-V and the Hyper-V R1 release has been incredibly stable and reliable. So, what did I find?

The Video: No Facts Just FUD.

Not much. Where are the details? There are no facts provided. What Hyper-V build was this? The beta? What was the configuration being tested? Who posted this? Why didn't they contact Microsoft support? I mean there's literally no data other than a defamatory statement at the beginning of the video implying that Hyper-V had something to do with some downtime at TechNet/MSDN. The SQL team and Operations responded to this days ago. In short, Hyper-V had nothing to do with the outage.

So, why would someone create such a video? Let's dig a little deeper.

The Poster.

The poster, who doesn't appear on the video, doesn't state what company he works for or provide any context. Gee, I wonder where he works?

<drum roll please>

Introducing Scott Drummonds, VMware Product Marketing.

image

Gosh, I wonder why Scott didn't mention he works for VMware?

Very professional Scott.

No signs of desperation there at all.

Looks like I'll need to provide the facts here.

What I Do Know.

  1. In the first 7 months of Hyper-V RTM availability, we've had over 750,000 downloads of Hyper-V gold bits.
  2. Hyper-V is the fastest growing x86/x64 hypervisor in history. We are laser focused on our customers and providing high performance, high quality virtualization for everyone from small business to Fortune 500 customers.
  3. We have hundreds of Hyper-V case studies from customers worldwide and we're winning new customers daily.
  4. Hyper-V continues to power MSDN, TechNet and Microsoft.com as well as numerous other MS properties. Microsoft.com continues to receive over a BILLION hits per month and there has been no downtime to any of these internet properties running atop Hyper-V. Period.
  5. Of those 750,000+ downloads, the number of support calls we have received on Hyper-V is less than .02%. (Yes, a minimal fraction of a percent.)

So, in terms of reliability, stability and support, not bad. (It's not like we released any patches resulting in days of downtime. HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, HERE, & HERE)

Hmm. Still Want To Know More.

All said, I still wasn't satisfied. On the Hyper-V team, we run thousands of stress tests per week and the stress tests we run are far more invasive than the test in this video. So, I consulted our Hyper-V Supportability Program Manager and dug deeper. I wanted to know if we've had any Hyper-V crashes reported. Here's what I found out.

Of the 750,000 downloads, we've had 3 reports of crashes under stress and with the same error code as seen in the video bugcheck (0x00020001). The solution in all three cases was to upgrade the server BIOS which solved the problem. This can happen as hypervisors interact very closely with the hardware and BIOS updates generally include updated microcode for processors oftentimes to address errata.

In case you're wondering, VMware has had similar crashes with older BIOSes as well. Here.

Those are the facts. Now back to our regularly scheduled Hyper-V goodness.

TechEd Next Week!

Next week is TechEd in Los Angeles and a number of us from the virtualization team will be there in Los Angeles. We've got numerous sessions covering Hyper-V R2, Virtual Machine Manager and more. Hope to see you there!

Jeff Woolsey

Principal Group Program Manager

Windows Server, Hyper-V

P.S. It appears Keith Ward has seen through this veneer of FUD and blogged as well. HERE.

Your comment has been posted.   Close
Thank you, your comment requires moderation so it may take a while to appear.   Close
Leave a Comment
  • PingBack from http://www.netdeluxo.com/blog/blogs/windows-virtualization-team-blog-hyper-v-winning-dailyvmware/

  • Interesting.

    I ran across this video roughly a week ago and couldn't believe it. I work for a small business that provides IT services for other small businesses - Hyper-V is a tremendous value for us. We've had a few issues with Hyper-V backup (that were resolved by hotfixes from our backup application vendor and MS hotfixes), but otherwise all the machines we have deployed running Hyper-V (about 10) have been stable - some of them even ran the RC with production workloads.

    It's nice to see a statement from Microsoft on this - i always keep our servers BIOS/Firmware up to date, but apparently VMware doesn't ;)

  • Bah, MS is full of crap playing the innocent card here.  How else do you explain showing up at VMworld 2008 with your poker chip marketing campaign?

  • I think you mistakenly mentioned Scott Lowe and linked to a Keith Ward blog article.

  • Virtualization Nation, I thought we were done with this topic yesterday. I really did. If you missed

  • The past few days there has been an very robust discussion through blogs and videos about how VMware

  • I'll be looking forward joint test where Microsoft and VMware teams test Hyper-V vs ESX with same workloads on same hardware. It would make my life as a customer who is choosing and sizing virtualization platform a lot easier.

  • I’m taking a breather from re-recording the voice track for a Video on Live Migration in Hyper-V. When

  • About a week ago Scott Drummonds from VMware Product Marketing posted an &quot;anonymous&quot; video

  • In der vergangenen Woche würde eine Reihe von “anonym” und unbegründeten Anschuldigungen über Microsoft

  • In the past week, a number of “anonymous” and unfounded accusations have been going around over Microsoft’s

  • In mijn inmiddels wat gedateerde publicatie http://onlinearchief.e-village.nl/download2.php?vartid=112263

  • Virtualization Nation, We were very busy last week with numerous virtualization announcements from TechEd.

  • Courtesy of the Microsoft Virtualization Team Blog: http://blogs.technet.com/virtualization/ VMware FUD

  • I know posts here have been sparse recently but I haven't neglected the blog, honest! Firstly, I was