Microsoft.com Operations

We are the operations team that runs the Microsoft.com sites.

Microsoft.com Operations Performance Analysis of IIS 7.0/Windows Server 2008

Microsoft.com Operations Performance Analysis of IIS 7.0/Windows Server 2008

  • Comments 11
  • Likes

Now that Windows Server 2008 has been released earlier this year many enterprises are assessing the value proposition of moving to the Windows Server 2008 and IIS 7.0.  As an IT Pro or decision maker in this process you want real world working proof to make your decision clearer.  Sure, the new file based configuration system and modular architecture of IIS 7.0 make administrating your web servers a whole lot more flexible.  But how does it perform against its predecessor IIS 6.0 / Windows Server 2003?

 

Microsoft.com Operations has been an early and active adopters of IIS 7.0 / Windows Server 2008.  We actually started running a single server on the www.microsoft.com site back in June 2005.  We set out to answer this question.  Is IIS 7.0 / Windows Server 2008 more performant then IIS 6.0 / Windows Server 2003?  We performed a side by side performance analysis on the www.microsoft.com site which was taking live internet traffic during peak traffic hours.

 

During this performance assessment we found that the CPU usage was higher on Microsoft Windows Server 2008 RTM servers, which is driven by the higher number of RPS the servers were handling.  As mentioned below the hardware load balancers are sending more traffic to the Windows Server 2008 RTM servers (31% more RPS) as they are completing the outstanding web requests faster than the W2K3 SP2 server.  A good metric listed below is the “efficiency” or “cost” of the number of requests per CPU cycle (RPS / CPU Utilization %).  Using this metric, IIS 7.0/W2K8 RTM is over 10% more efficient then IIS 6.0/WS03 SP2 in handling live web platform traffic for the www.microsoft.com site.

 

Listed below the graphical data results is the methodology used in this performance analysis.

Performance Metrics

W2K3 SP2

WS2K8 RTM

Change

RPS / CPU Utilization (%) =  Requests per CPU Cycle

4.36

4.84

10.9%

 

 

W2K3 SP2

W2K8 RTM

Change

Performance Indicators

A

B

(A-B)/A

CPU Utilization (%)

44.8%

52.8%

-17.9%

Web Service -Total Methods Requests/Sec “RPS”

194

255

31.4%

Web Service – Current Connections

280

294

5.0%

Load Balancing –  Current Client Connections

116

116

.NET CLR Memory – % Time in GC

1.1%

2.5%

 

Server Efficiency (RPS/ CPU %) – Efficiency of serving live web platform traffic

W2K3 SP2     4.36   requests per CPU cycle”

W2K8 RTM   4.84   ~ 10.9% increased efficiency

 SRV Efficiency

 

CPU Utilization (%)

W2K3 SP2     44.8%

W2K8 RTM   52.8%   ~ 17.9% degradation (This is impacted by the increased RPS the W2K8 servers are handling)

 CPU Utilization

 

Web Service – Total Methods Requests/Sec (RPS)

W2K3 SP2     194

W2K8 RTM    255   ~ 31.4% more traffic is being sent to the W2K8 RTM servers

 Web Svc Total Methods

 

Web Service – Current Connections

W2K3 SP2     280

W2K8 RTM   294   ~ 5% increase

 WEBSvc Current Connections

 Load Balancing – Current Client Connections

W2K3 SP2     116

W2K8 RTM   116   Equal – as the hardware load balancer maintains the same amount of outstanding open client connections.

 HW Load Balancing 

.NET CLR Memory – % Time in GC

W2K3 SP2    1.1%

W2K8 RTM   2.5%  No significant degradation in “Time in GC”

.Net CLR Memory 

 

Performance Overview and methodology:

Site: www.microsoft.com 

During this assessment the live www.microsoft.com site was comprised on 80 servers.  There were four load balanced clusters of twenty servers each, located in multiple datacenters.  This performance analysis was developed by using a single twenty server cluster on the www.microsoft.com site.  The cluster is comprised of 19 Windows Server 2008 RTM servers (W2K8 RTM) and a single Windows Server 2003 SP2 (W2K3 SP2) server all taking live internet facing traffic.  This Lone Windows Server 2003 has become quite famous.  In fact, he actually has his own blog located at http://blogs.technet.com/windowsserver/pages/about-lone-server.aspx

 

Hardware:

  Model: HP DL585 G1 (4 dual-core CPUs)

  RAM: 32GB 

 

OS:

 Windows Server 2008 RTM (Build: 6.0.6001.18000) Enterprise version x64

 

Load Balancing:

We are using a hardware load balancing solution.  The load balancing algorithm we are using is based on “Least Current Client Connections” to each load balanced member server of the cluster (not round robin, or other any other load balancing algorithms).  The hardware load balancer will maintain the same number of current client connections to each member of the cluster.  So if a W2K8 server is completing web requests faster than a W2K3 server, the load balancer will send more traffic to the server W2K8 RTM server.

 

Methodology:

We gathered performance monitor logs for 72 hours during peak traffic (Monday - Wednesday) for a cluster of www.microsoft.com web servers.  In all the charts above the W2K8 RTM data is based on an average of all the W2K8 RTM servers in a single cluster.  While the W2K3 SP2 data is based on the single (Lone) server that was in rotation.

Comments
  • If you are in search of real world performance numbers on Windows Server 2008, go here. It is basically the Microsoft.com sysadmins that have been running W2K8 and W2K3 side by side, serving out Microsoft.com’s content.

  • Now that Windows Server 2008 has been released earlier this year many enterprises are assessing the value

  • Interested in knowing what kind of performance gains you can expect from IIS7?  Performance is a

  • Thought TechEd was as good a time as any to give you all some great news…I’VE BEEN UPGRADED! Well, it’s

  • IIS7のセミナーを2年続けてきて最近増えてきているのはパフォーマンスは?というご質問です。より実践が近い時には当然判断基準が欲しいのは小職の過去の経験からも自明の理です。マイクロソフトはシステムインテグレーションを本業としておらず、パートナー様とともにビジネスを推進するモデルのため、現場での実践値の蓄積がすごく多いわけではなく、テスト時やマイクロソフトが運用している環境の情報が最初に事例として出てくることが歴史的に多いです。しかし、最近事情が変わってきており、まずは社内事例を早くということでマイクロソフトの社内システムに関する情報を一生懸

  • WebIntroducingIE=EmulateIE7Microsoft.comOperationsPerformanceAnalysisofIIS7.0/WindowsServ...

  • Web Introducing IE=EmulateIE7 Microsoft.com Operations Performance Analysis of IIS 7.0/Windows Server

  • The Microsoft.com posted some real world numbers on IIS 7. They show how much IIS has improved performance

  • IIS Hacks has been running on IIS 7 for about 2 weeks now and feels more responsive. It has a faster first byte response when the server is under load. Like the MS Sys Admins, there is higher CPU utilization.

  • Learn how the Microsoft.com operations team meets the demands for one of the top 5 websites on the Internet today. The team supports the server product teams at Microsoft by "dogfooding" products such as Windows Server 2008, SQL Server 2008 and IIS7 years

  • Which tool was used to conduct the Performance Analysis of IIS 6.0 on Windows Server 2003 SP2???

Your comment has been posted.   Close
Thank you, your comment requires moderation so it may take a while to appear.   Close
Leave a Comment