WOW! I was receiving quite a few emails asking about the ability to perform an in-place upgrade from Windows 7 RC to Windows 7 RTM so on July 8, 2009, I put up a nice post on my blog on that. OMG! I did not realize I had stirred up an angry ant hill. I received a few comments on my blog and a boat load of emails in my inbox referencing that post and asking me even more questions.
Rather than post another set of comments to the original post, I thought I would put up a new post with some clarification points.
I’ll start with the easy items first and then work down the list to the “tough” ones.
That pretty much addresses all the questions I’ve received regarding this topic. Not all were stated exactly as I asked them, but when I break it down, they fell into one or more of the seven items I just addressed above. Item 7 is kinda the “catch all” for the ones related to folks who don’t have the original installation media but have already wiped out their systems and installed Windows 7 RC onto it. Until I know the actual requirements for using the Upgrade Media, I don’t know what to tell you in terms of what you’ll have to do to get to RTM.
I hope this helps to clarify things other than item seven. I am keeping an eye out on the Windows team blog so as soon as I see an update, I will also post an update on my blog. Thanks for your patience.
Thanks for taking the time to clarify everything up. I was quite surprised to see PCWorld quoted you on that last post after having read it myself the day before or so.
I totally agree with you on the issue of trying to perfrom an upgrade from the RC beta. Why would anyone do such a thing in the first place? I'm believing that those people are the one's who don't have or are too lazy to make a copy of their data so they want to take the easy way out and do an upgrade instead.
Anyways, keep up the good work Harold.
Thanks Harold for staying on top of these issues.
RE: Item #7. Nice of MS to promote a big-discount upgrade offer without really knowing who can and cannot actually use it (or at least, without publicly providing the **exact** requirements at the time of the offer). There certainly seems to be a lot of potential here for people who purchased the upgrade to learn later that in fact they will not be able to use it, or at least that the limitations on it may not make it the best installation option.
Love the fact that when Windows 7 is released I am going to have to reinstall approximately 400GB of games and another 200 GB of applications... not allowing an upgrade from Windows 7 RC to Windows 7 final while allowing an upgrade from XP or Vista to Windows 7 RC is just ridiculous.
Yes, and I am going to have to install over 3,000 games and 2 Billion applications too. Foolish liars.
Charles: We do not allow an in place upgrade from Windows XP to Windows 7. We only allow this from a licensing perspective, but not technical perspective.
By reading your blog I've figured out the answer to 2 of my 3 questions...
1. Upgrade over installed XP vs. clean HDD, and insert XP disk? Insert the disk, direct upgrade of XP doesn't work.
2. Upgrade installed Windows 7 RC by changing Serial Number? NO, doesn't work.
But, I couldn't find the answer to my 3rd question. Change I change an installed 32-bit VISTA to 64-bit Windows 7 on Upgrade?
On the same subject, if I have the XP CD and want to install 64-bit Windows 7, can I?
One more question.
When I tried to install W7 on a 37GB SCSI drive, it wouldn't "see" it, instead choosing non-bootable SATA drives. Is there some kind of a HDD limitation on the install?
I have Windows 7 RC 32-bit installed. Can i do an inplace upgrade to the RC 64-bit version?
its easy to do the inplace upgrade from rc to RTM, i've done it; took no time at all :-) See my URL.
I’ve upgraded several machines from different versions of Vista to Windows 7 and had one instance that was stumping both me and the upgrade process.
I finally worked out that becuase I had dual boot (Vista & W2K8) on the machine, the process stalled at 20% of the gathering files, settings and programs stage without any further progress being made.
Removing the dual boot capability with BCDEDIT and deleting the partition (it was only for testing so I was lucky to be able to take this approach) has sorted it and the upgrade is going well now…
For people who have asked about upgrading to 64-bit from 32-bit Vista ... No, this cannot be done in place.
Microsoft released a chart around a month ago which detailed in-place upgrade paths.
You can only (in-place) upgrade from Vista 32-bit to Windows 7 32-bit, or from Vista 64-bit to Windows 7 64-bit.
Anything else (XP, 32 or 64-bit) will result in your old Windows folder being renamed (so you can later retrieve any important files from it) and a new "Windows" directory created for your new Windows 7 install.
Since the Beta's is creating so many problems, why don't you all just forget about the Beta's and go on straight to the Final release? I mean, stop releasing the Beta's when you are unsure whether there WILL be an upgrades to the Final. This is what we always think - 'we will eventually be able to upgrade to the final version when it is out in the market.. just like previously.' Please, scrap the Beta thing and just go on to the final, thank you.. now I have to think a way to transfer everything from my LAPTOP (Yes, I only have one PC, where suppose am I going to test the RC?) to Windows 7. or maybe I will just sell the laptop and get myself a MAC.
In all the testing I have done with Microsoft Operating Systems (I started beta testing with Windows 95 and have participated in every one since), I do not ever remember Microsoft supporting an in-place upgrade from Beta to RTM. Maybe I missed something, but I don't believe so. I'm sorry, but no one is forcing you to test the beta or release candidates of the products - that is your choice.
In terms of your last statement of moving to Mac, that is your choice. I am not being arrogant with this statement, but at the same time, I am not holding a gun to anyone's head regarding using Windows Vista or Windows 7. I hope there is enough value in Windows 7 that people will choose to go with it. If you do not believe there is value, it is indeed your choice to continue using Windows or a Mac or Linux or whatever OS you choose to use.
I am not getting into a "religous" battle on this.